Pemex CEO criticizes Moody’s decision to cut its rating


The top executive at Petroleos Mexicanos slammed the decision by Moody’s Investors Service to cut the state oil producer’s credit rating further into junk, calling the move “shameful.”

Pemex, as the company is known, “completely disagrees” with the downgrade and believes Moody’s acted unprofessionally, Octavio Romero, the driller’s chief executive officer, said Wednesday on its second-quarter earnings call. On Tuesday, the rating agency cited high liquidity needs and increasing business risk in announcing its decision.

“It seems to us that it’s an action taken by the credit rating agency that lacks professionalism, ethics — in short, it’s something shameful,” Romero said.

In a press conference after the downgrade, Moody’s analyst Nymia Almeida said in response to a question about Romero’s comments that the agency applies the same standard to other, similar companies.

Petroleos Mexicanos CEO Octavio Romero Interview
Octavio RomeroPhotographer: Alejandro Cegarra/Bloomberg

Pemex has struggled to invest in new fields because of budgetary constraints, a large tax burden, and a debt load that’s the highest of any oil company. On Wednesday, the driller reported rising oil output for a second straight quarter. But the production gains came in large part due to an increase in extraction of condensate — used to dilute some heavy crude — rather than the company’s flagship crude for export.

Mexico’s new government has pledged to return Pemex to its former glory by dismantling the liberalizing energy reforms of the previous administration. President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador’s administration has canceled new oil and gas auctions, designed Pemex as the operator of a giant field discovered by foreign companies, and cracked down on private fuel importers to give the state driller the upper hand.

Yet critics argue that the nationalistic approach to Mexico’s oil sector puts too much financial pressure on Pemex to develop oil fields without partners and that the government’s decision to focus on gasoline independence distracts from the company’s core job of drilling.

Pemex has struggled to generate free cash flow

Moody’s cut Pemex to Ba3, three levels below investment grade, from Ba2. Its outlook remains negative. The company faces high debt maturities while it expands refining capacity and production, Moody’s analysts Almeida and Marcos Schmidt wrote in the decision.

While Pemex bonds sank earlier in the day after Moody’s downgraded the credit, bonds maturing in 2031 nearly erased the day’s losses after the company reported earnings. The debt trades close to 96.6 cents on the dollar, little changed on the day.

In May, Pemex announced the takeover Royal Dutch Shell Plc’s 50% stake in its refinery in Deer Park, Texas, for $596 million. The Mexican oil giant is also building a seventh refinery near the Dos Bocas maritime port in the state of Tabasco at a cost likely to exceed $10 billion.

Moody’s justification for cutting Pemex’s rating demonstrates “obvious logical contradictions” and the company will issue a detailed statement expressing its disagreement on Wednesday, Romero said. He noted that the acquisition of the Deer Park refinery and the construction of Dos Bocas are being funded with federal resources.

Pemex reported net income for the second quarter of 14.4 billion pesos ($721 million), compared with a net loss the previous quarter of 37.4 billion pesos. The company saw oil and condensate production rose by a slight 1.2% to 1.736 million barrels a day in the second quarter compared with the previous quarter. Output in the second quarter rose 3.8% compared with the same period a year ago.

The company’s financial debt rose to $115.1 billion at the end of June, from $113.9 billion at the end of March. Pemex said it didn’t receive any proceeds for the first half of its 2019-2021 hedging program because observed prices were above the strike price. Its current hedging strategy corresponds to about 50% of the full year 2021 exposure.

Pemex is expected to receive additional financial aid from the government this year. Mexico’s tax chief Raquel Buenrostro told El Financiero earlier this month that incoming Finance Minister Rogelio Ramirez de la O is going to prioritize refinancing Pemex.

In March, Pemex said that the government would absorb some $6.4 billion of its debt amortization payments. President Lopez Obrador also announced in February a new credit stimulus that will apply to the taxes Pemex pays on hydrocarbons, capped at $3.6 billion.

Source: El Financiero

Mexico Daily Post